Asking the Court to Remove Yourself or Someone Else from a Deed
(Part of the Real Property work we do)
You’re locked into a deed with your siblings - land you inherited from your parents. Everyone agreed 4 years ago to sell the property, but your brother is still living there and has no discernable plan to leave. As a cotenant, he has a right to live there. But, you also have rights.
Contribution, Accounting, and Quantum Meruit
The equitable right of contribution is the right of a party to seek contribution towards expenses from another party. "The general rule of contribution is that one who is compelled to pay or satisfy the whole or to bear more than his aliquot share of the common burden or obligation, upon which several persons are equally liable or which they are bound to discharge, is entitled to contribution against the others to obtain from them payment of their respective shares." Caldwell v Fox, 394 Mich 401, 417; 231 NW2d 46 (1975). When a Court ‘sits in equity’, it means that the judge will use their judgment to place both parties on even footing. This is not the same as the more common role of the Court, which is legal interpretation and application. The Court sitting in equity does not strictly interpret the law and apply the facts of the case to it, but rather uses principles of fairness and justice to resolve a dispute.
Accounting is the right of a party to examine financial information. Parties who own property together will have expenses. The ability to examine and understand the distributions a party can expect to receive, or the debt the party has accrued, is integral to an orderly system of justice. An accounting is another equitable remedy that allows one party to demand the financial records of another - at least in relation to relevant property.
Quantum Meruit is another equitable remedy which asks a Court to order that money which unjustly enriched someone else be given back.
Partition
A Partition action is also an equitable remedy to split or sell property so that a co-owner can get out of the benefits and burdens of ownership. There are multiple avenues this can go down, so bear with me.
A tenant in common, or joint tenant without rights of survivorship, can go to court and request partition. The traditional common law partition action would split a parcel of property into multiple sub-parcels, but with smaller parcels and township zoning, the law had to evolve. If a parcel is too small, or if splitting would be impractical (such as when there is one house on the property, which of course cannot be split into two houses), the Court can instead order a sale of the property. The property will be appraised and then given to a court-appointed receiver who will conduct a sale of the property - usually at auction. The parties will each receive their equitable portion of the sale. The sale is often for a lower price than listing on the open market with a realtor and waiting for a buyer.
A tenant in common heir who received the property from their relative can follow the new partition law, MCL 600.3402. This law adds a step which allows a co-owner to buy out the interest of the other owners at an appraised price. While this option is always available as a settlement option outside of court, now it is an explicit court-ordered option which helps to keep property in a family, and prevents the lower value that often comes with an ordinary partition action (sale at auction instead of on the open market).
This leaves one more scenario - Joint Tenants with Rights of Survivorship (JTWROS). This scenario is complicated. Under Albro v. Allen, 434 Mich. 271, 454 N.W.2d 85 (Mich. 1990), a binding Michigan Supreme Court precedent (but see also, Olson v. Bosanac, No. 341478 (Mich. App. Dec 20, 2018)(unpublished) and Hrit v. McKeon, No. 317988 (Mich. App. Feb 03, 2015)(unpublished), a JTWROS is basically split into two types of interest. These two interests are a life estate interest and a contingent remainder interest. A life estate is the right to use a property during one’s lifetime. A contingent remainder is the right to own a property after the lifetime of some person is over. With JTWROS for person A and person B, the contingent remainders for each of them measure the lifetime of the other, and upon the death of the other the survivor receives the now vested remainder interest, getting the whole property.
Under Albro and the other two unpublished cases, the consensus seems to be that a life estate is something that can be partitioned, but a court will not partition the contingent remainder. This means that a property can be split for the lifetimes of Persons A and B, and even sold to some third party, but upon the death of person A or B, the remainder interest goes to the survivor of them, even if a third party owns the property through the partition and sale of the life estate. Whew.
The Hrit court held that because a life estate is not practically marketable, the Court could not force a partition. The Olson court found that at the early summary disposition phase of the case, it isn’t possible to say whether a life estate is practically marketable - that is an evidentiary question, not a question of law.
While likely nobody is going to buy a life estate in a property, only for the previous co-owner to then receive the property upon the death of the seller, parties can voluntarily alienate (sell) their remainder interest in the property. This is under MCL 554.35, which states that future interests in property are alienable. However, a court cannot force this. If one person sells their remainder interest and the other does not, as the Albro court puts it in footnote 2:
“[2] If Allen predeceases Albro, then, upon Allen's death, Albro's contingent remainder will be realized and she will acquire title to the land in fee. If Albro predeceases Allen, then Allen's contingent remainder, which was transferred to Kinzer, will be realized and Kinzer will acquire the land in fee.”
Under this scenario, the buyer Kinzer would not receive the property after Allen’s death, but would after Albro’s death. It is a gamble about who dies first. The one thing we know about gambling is that odds can be valued. I believe that because odds can be valued, the approach of the Olson court makes more sense. A Court should be able to partition property and value a life estate, even if it must rely on testimony by an expert actuary. There is nothing quite like valuing a life in dollars to make you feel like a ghoul in this profession.
The conclusion of the Albro Court does a fine job of summarizing the law:
“The interest which was conveyed by the deed to Carol Allen and Helen Albro "as joint tenants with full rights of survivorship" was a joint life estate with dual contingent remainders. The contingent remainder of either cotenant may not be destroyed by any act of the other. Thus, we hold that either cotenant may transfer her interest in the joint life estate and such a transfer has no effect on the contingent remainders. Upon the death of either of the original cotenants, the other cotenant, or any person to whom she has transferred her contingent remainder, takes the whole estate. We further hold that the joint life estate may be partitioned without affecting the contingent remainders.”
Conclusion
There you have it. A partition action might not be practically available to you, but likely at least a Contribution and Accounting action will be. With any of these actions, settling may be preferable to litigating, which could include selling a co-owner’s interest in the property to another co-owner. We will typically examine the situation fully, send a demand letter outlining the legal rights of remedies of the parties and requesting settlement, and then escalate to a summons and complaint if necessary. Please contact us if you need help getting out of your deed.